Dialidol predictions:

1) Hollie

2) Phil

3) Josh

4) Jessica

5) Skylar

6) Elise

Idol By The Numbers predictions:

1) Jessica

2) Phil

3) Hollie

4) Josh

5) Elise

6) Skylar - It was noted however that Skylar tends to always be higher than her ranking

So it looks like, once you consider the Skylar phenomenon, both predictions had Elise as most likely to go home. And both correctly had Skylar and Elise in the bottom 3 while getting the other contestant incorrect. Overall which predictions do you think made more sense based on their performances?